The Actual History
India has emerged as a significant player in the global technology landscape, but as of 2025, it remains primarily positioned as a service provider rather than a technological innovator in cutting-edge fields like artificial intelligence. The country's technology sector has been characterized by several key developments:
-
IT Services Dominance: India established itself as the world's back office, with companies like TCS, Infosys, and Wipro becoming global IT services giants. This sector contributes approximately 8% to India's GDP and employs over 5 million people directly.
-
Growing Startup Ecosystem: India's startup ecosystem has expanded dramatically, with over 100 unicorns (startups valued at over $1 billion) by 2025. Bengaluru (formerly Bangalore) has emerged as one of Asia's most important tech hubs, often called "India's Silicon Valley."
-
Digital Public Infrastructure: India has built impressive digital public infrastructure, including the Aadhaar biometric ID system (covering over 1.3 billion people), the Unified Payments Interface (UPI) for digital payments, and the Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC).
-
Tech Talent Pool: The country produces approximately 1.5 million engineering graduates annually, creating one of the world's largest technical talent pools. However, studies suggest only 20-25% are immediately employable in high-tech roles without additional training.
-
AI Policy Development: In 2021, India released its National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence, followed by the National Program on AI in 2023, which allocated approximately $1.2 billion for AI research and implementation over five years.
Despite these strengths, India faces significant challenges in becoming a true AI superpower:
-
Research Gap: India produces only about 3% of top-tier global AI research papers, compared to approximately 28% from the United States and 25% from China.
-
Compute Infrastructure Limitations: The country lacks indigenous high-performance computing capabilities and advanced semiconductor manufacturing, remaining dependent on imported chips and cloud services.
-
Investment Disparity: Annual AI investment in India (approximately $3.5 billion in 2024) remains a fraction of that in the United States (approximately $80 billion) and China (approximately $50 billion).
-
Data Governance Challenges: While India has vast data resources, it struggles with comprehensive data governance frameworks that balance innovation, privacy, and security.
-
Brain Drain: Many of India's top AI researchers and entrepreneurs work for foreign companies or universities, with approximately 8% of Silicon Valley's technical workforce being of Indian origin.
The global AI landscape remains dominated by the United States and China, with companies like OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, Anthropic, Baidu, and ByteDance leading in foundation models and AI applications. The European Union has positioned itself as a regulatory leader with the AI Act, while countries like South Korea, Japan, and Israel have carved out specialized niches.
India's approach to AI has been pragmatic, focusing on applications in healthcare, agriculture, education, and smart cities rather than competing directly in foundation model development or semiconductor manufacturing. The country has leveraged its digital public infrastructure to create AI applications with social impact, but has not yet emerged as a rule-maker in global AI governance or a leader in fundamental AI research and innovation.
This historical context raises an intriguing counterfactual question: What if India had pursued a more ambitious strategy and successfully positioned itself as a global AI superpower, challenging the US-China duopoly in this transformative technology?
The Point of Divergence
In this alternate timeline, India's path toward AI supremacy begins in late 2023 with a pivotal shift in national strategy. Rather than continuing its traditional role as a technology services provider, the Indian government launches an ambitious "AI Sovereignty Initiative" with unprecedented political backing and resource allocation.
The initiative represents a fundamental rethinking of India's technological trajectory, combining state direction with private innovation in a distinctive model that differs from both American market-led and Chinese state-led approaches. Several key developments characterize this point of divergence:
-
Massive Resource Mobilization: The government commits 1.5% of GDP (approximately $50 billion annually) to AI development over a five-year period, creating a dedicated AI Development Fund that dwarfs previous technology investments.
-
Regulatory Fast-Tracking: Parliament passes the Digital Innovation Act of 2023, which creates specialized regulatory sandboxes for AI development, streamlines data sharing while enhancing privacy protections, and establishes expedited approval processes for AI applications in critical sectors.
-
Talent Repatriation Program: A concerted effort to reverse brain drain brings thousands of Indian AI researchers and entrepreneurs back from Silicon Valley, offering competitive compensation packages, research freedom, and opportunities to build technologies specifically addressing Indian and Global South challenges.
-
Indigenous Computing Infrastructure: Rather than remaining dependent on foreign cloud providers and semiconductors, India launches a crash program to develop sovereign computing capabilities, including specialized AI chips designed for India's specific needs and energy constraints.
-
Data Advantage Leveraging: India begins systematically utilizing its unique data advantage—diverse data from 1.4 billion citizens across multiple languages and contexts—while implementing a "Data Trust" model that ensures ethical usage and citizen benefit-sharing.
The initiative gains unexpected momentum when a consortium of Indian tech companies and research institutions achieves a significant breakthrough in early 2024: developing a novel approach to training large language models that requires substantially less computing power while maintaining performance, particularly for low-resource languages. This "Frugal AI" approach plays to India's strengths and constraints, allowing the country to leapfrog certain stages of AI development.
By mid-2024, the first generation of Indian foundation models begins to emerge, with distinctive capabilities in multilingual processing (handling India's 22 official languages plus dozens of regional dialects), operating effectively on lower-cost hardware, and demonstrating superior performance in Global South contexts where Western models often struggle.
This technological breakthrough coincides with growing global concerns about AI systems primarily designed for Western contexts and values, creating an opening for India to position its AI approach as more inclusive, accessible, and aligned with the needs of developing economies—where the majority of the world's population lives.
Immediate Aftermath
Technological Acceleration
The immediate impact of India's AI initiative manifests in several technological breakthroughs:
-
Multilingual AI Dominance: Indian models quickly establish superiority in processing non-Western languages and cultural contexts. By late 2024, the "Bhasha" model supports over 100 languages, including many with limited digital resources, giving India a decisive advantage in global markets where English is not the primary language.
-
Frugal AI Deployment: The Indian approach to "AI for the masses" leads to models that can run effectively on smartphones and low-cost edge devices rather than requiring expensive cloud infrastructure. This dramatically expands AI accessibility across India and similar markets.
-
Sector-Specific Applications: Targeted AI solutions for agriculture, healthcare, education, and public services begin showing impressive results. The "KisanAI" agricultural advisory system, deployed across rural India, demonstrates 30% yield improvements while reducing water and fertilizer usage.
-
Digital Public Infrastructure Integration: India's existing digital public infrastructure becomes a powerful accelerant, with AI capabilities integrated into the UPI payment system, Aadhaar identity verification, and public service delivery platforms, creating the world's most advanced AI-powered governance systems.
Economic Transformation
The economic landscape begins shifting rapidly:
-
Startup Explosion: Venture capital floods into Indian AI startups, with investment increasing fivefold to approximately $18 billion in 2024. The number of AI unicorns jumps from 5 to 28 within twelve months.
-
Export Shift: India's technology exports begin transitioning from services to products and intellectual property. By mid-2025, AI-related exports reach $25 billion annually and continue growing rapidly.
-
Job Market Evolution: While some traditional IT service roles face disruption, new job categories emerge in AI development, implementation, and oversight. Net technology employment increases by approximately 800,000 positions in the first year.
-
Regional Tech Hubs: Beyond Bengaluru, specialized AI clusters develop in Hyderabad (healthcare AI), Pune (manufacturing AI), Chennai (language AI), and Ahmedabad (agricultural AI), creating a more distributed innovation ecosystem.
Geopolitical Repositioning
India's emergence as an AI power reshapes international technology politics:
-
Global South Leadership: India positions itself as the technology champion for developing nations, offering AI solutions designed for their specific challenges and contexts rather than Western-centric approaches.
-
Strategic Partnerships: Several countries including Brazil, Indonesia, South Africa, and the UAE form strategic AI partnerships with India, preferring its approach to those of the US or China.
-
Regulatory Influence: India begins advocating for a "third way" in AI governance—distinct from both the EU's precautionary approach and the US market-led model—emphasizing responsible innovation with developmental priorities.
-
Corporate Reactions: Major Western and Chinese tech companies scramble to adapt, with some establishing expanded R&D centers in India to tap into the emerging ecosystem, while others face challenges as their models underperform in non-Western contexts.
Domestic Transformations
Within India, the AI initiative catalyzes broader changes:
-
Educational Reform: Universities rapidly revamp computer science and engineering curricula to emphasize AI development. Vocational training programs in AI implementation spread across smaller cities and towns.
-
Infrastructure Priorities: Digital infrastructure receives accelerated investment, with high-speed connectivity reaching 85% of the population by mid-2025, up from 65% previously.
-
Public Perception Shift: Success in AI development becomes a source of national pride, with public support for the initiative reaching 78% approval ratings despite its significant costs.
-
Governance Innovation: State governments begin competing to implement AI solutions for public services, creating a race to demonstrate technology-driven governance improvements.
Long-term Impact
India's Global Position
Over the following five years, India's position in the global order undergoes a fundamental transformation:
-
Technological Triad: By 2030, a clear technological triad emerges in global AI development—the United States, China, and India—each with distinctive approaches, strengths, and spheres of influence.
-
Economic Leapfrogging: India's GDP growth accelerates to a sustained 9-10% annually, putting it on track to become the world's third-largest economy by 2028, earlier than previously projected.
-
Diplomatic Leverage: Technology becomes India's primary source of diplomatic influence, with its AI partnerships extending across Africa, Southeast Asia, and Latin America, creating a technology-based alignment distinct from traditional geopolitical blocs.
-
Standards Setting: India becomes a key player in international technology standards bodies, successfully advocating for inclusive design requirements and multilingual benchmarks in global AI standards.
Technological Evolution
The nature of AI development itself evolves under Indian influence:
-
Accessibility Revolution: The Indian emphasis on frugal AI running on modest hardware democratizes access globally. By 2028, over 3 billion people in developing countries have access to AI tools customized for their needs and contexts.
-
Specialized vs. General AI: While Western research continues focusing on artificial general intelligence, Indian development emphasizes specialized systems solving concrete problems in agriculture, healthcare, education, and governance.
-
Human-AI Collaboration Models: India pioneers approaches where AI augments human capabilities rather than replacing workers, creating influential models for maintaining employment while increasing productivity.
-
Indigenous Innovation Paradigms: Traditional knowledge systems begin influencing AI development, with Indian approaches incorporating principles from ancient logical traditions like Nyaya and holistic systems thinking.
Social Transformations
Indian society undergoes profound changes:
-
Rural-Urban Rebalancing: AI-enabled remote work and improved agricultural productivity slow urban migration, revitalizing rural economies and reducing pressure on overcrowded cities.
-
Educational Transformation: The education system shifts from rote learning toward critical thinking and creativity, as AI handles routine cognitive tasks while humans focus on innovation and judgment.
-
Healthcare Revolution: AI-powered diagnostics and treatment planning extend quality healthcare to underserved populations, with life expectancy increasing by three years between 2025-2030.
-
Linguistic Renaissance: Advanced language AI preserves and revitalizes regional languages and dialects, reversing the trend toward English dominance and supporting cultural diversity.
Global Economic Shifts
The economic landscape continues evolving:
-
Value Chain Repositioning: India moves up the global technology value chain, transitioning from providing services to exporting high-value AI products, intellectual property, and eventually its own technology platforms.
-
South-South Technology Trade: A new pattern of technology transfer emerges between India and other developing nations, bypassing traditional North-South technology diffusion models.
-
Investment Patterns: Global capital increasingly flows toward Indian technology ventures, with Mumbai and Bengaluru joining Silicon Valley and Shanghai as premier destinations for technology investment.
-
New Business Models: India pioneers AI business models suited to lower-income markets, including micro-subscription services, community ownership structures, and public-private partnerships that later spread globally.
Challenges and Adaptations
The transition is not without significant challenges:
-
Inequality Concerns: Despite efforts to ensure inclusive benefits, AI-driven economic transformation initially widens some disparities between digital haves and have-nots, requiring targeted policy interventions.
-
Ethical Dilemmas: India's rapid AI deployment surfaces unique ethical challenges, particularly around data governance in a diverse society with varying literacy levels and digital awareness.
-
International Tensions: As India's technological influence grows, it faces increasing pushback from established powers, including trade restrictions, intellectual property disputes, and cybersecurity challenges.
-
Environmental Pressures: The energy demands of expanded computing infrastructure create sustainability challenges, driving India to pioneer energy-efficient AI approaches and accelerate renewable energy deployment.
Expert Opinions
Dr. Lakshmi Chandrasekaran, Director of the Center for Responsible AI at the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, observes:
"India's emergence as an AI superpower represents more than just a shift in where technology is developed—it fundamentally changes what kind of AI the world prioritizes. The Western AI paradigm evolved in societies with abundant computing resources, relatively homogeneous populations, and post-industrial economies. Indian AI, by necessity and design, addresses different constraints: resource limitations, extraordinary diversity, and development challenges. This has produced AI systems that are more frugal, more adaptable to varied contexts, and more focused on solving concrete human problems rather than chasing theoretical capabilities. The global impact is profound—we're seeing a democratization of AI development and deployment that might never have occurred if the field had remained dominated by Silicon Valley and Beijing. The most significant long-term consequence may be that AI becomes a technology that works for the majority of humanity, not just for the wealthy economies that initially developed it."
Professor Michael Chen, Comparative Technology Policy Researcher at Stanford University, notes:
"What's most fascinating about India's AI trajectory is how it's created a distinctive third model of technology development—neither the American venture capital-driven approach nor the Chinese state-directed model. India has pioneered what we might call 'directed pluralism,' where government sets ambitious national missions and creates enabling infrastructure but allows a diverse ecosystem of players—from startups to research institutions to traditional businesses—to innovate within that framework. This approach has proven remarkably effective for AI development, combining the creativity of market competition with the strategic focus of national planning. We're now seeing other countries, particularly in Southeast Asia and Africa, studying and adapting this Indian model rather than simply importing American or Chinese approaches. This represents a significant shift in how emerging economies approach technology development and suggests we may see increasing divergence in innovation models rather than global convergence around a single approach."
Dr. Amina Okonkwo, Technology and Development Specialist at the United Nations Development Programme, states:
"The developmental impact of India's AI leadership cannot be overstated. For decades, we've seen technologies designed primarily for wealthy markets being awkwardly retrofitted for developing country contexts—often with poor results. India's approach inverted this model by designing AI specifically for resource-constrained environments with challenging infrastructure and diverse user needs. The results have been transformative, particularly in sectors like agriculture, healthcare, and education where Western AI solutions often failed to gain traction. The Indian agricultural AI systems that optimize for small landholdings, variable weather conditions, and limited connectivity have increased food security across multiple African countries in ways that previous agricultural technologies never achieved. Similarly, Indian healthcare AI designed to work with limited medical infrastructure has extended diagnostic capabilities to remote areas previously underserved. This represents a fundamental shift in the global technology diffusion pattern, with innovations increasingly flowing South-to-South rather than North-to-South, and often proving more effective for the majority of the world's population."
Further Reading
- The Coming Wave: Technology, Power, and the Twenty-first Century's Greatest Dilemma by Mustafa Suleyman
- Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity by Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson
- Branding India: An Incredible Story by Amitabh Kant
- The Art of Bitfulness: Finding Calm in the Chaos by Nandan Nilekani and Tanuj Bhojwani
- Rebooting India: Realizing a Billion Aspirations by Nandan Nilekani and Viral Shah
- Artificial Intelligence and International Economic Law: Disruption, Regulation, and Reconfiguration by Shin-yi Peng, Ching-Fu Lin, and Thomas Streinz